Samyak Drishti Magazine for Photographers in India & World

cropped-logo-both
Edit Content
Click on the Edit Content button to edit/add the content.

Nov 2020 Vol 01 | Issue 03

As long as the sun shines

Ian Willims interview by
Anirudha Cheoolkar

As long as the sun shines

These words are part of the treaty (treaty 8) which promised to protect and nurture the lands on which the indigenous population used to hunt and fish. The lands were granted to them back in 1899 for “as long as the sun shines”. Betraying the faith, the government gave away more than 90000 km 2 of that territory to international oil corporation. Ian Willms, a Canadian photojournalist has been following this systematic destruction of the forest lands & the lives of the peoples living there. His photographs are being showcased in Indian Photo Festival 2020 at Hyderabad, India, Portraying the sad devastation of land and lives of indigenous people.

While talking with him over the net, he said, “The Canadian oil sands are the largest, most environmentally destructive oil development on Earth. Giving rise to rare cancers, birth defects, lupus and other ailments which are occurring at alarmingly high rates.” He says further “Intense forest fires, driven by climate change, devastate the land that has yet to be impacted by
industrial development. Traditional Indigenous economies of hunting and fishing have been decimated, leaving First Nation band members with few options for employment outside of the very industry that’s consuming their traditional territory. In Fort Chipewyan, Alberta, locals will describe this process as a “slow-motion cultural genocide.” Meanwhile, the oil industry cities like Fort McMurray experience unprecedented economic growth.”

Ian is a freelance contributor to National Geographic, The New York Times, TIME, GEO, The Guardian and many others. His works have garnered support and accolades from The Eugene Smith Fund, World Press Photo, Sony World Photography Awards, Pictures of the Year International, The Canada Council for the Arts, the Lange-Taylor Prize et al, and been shown in
solo exhibitions at Visa pour l’Image, Lumix Festival for Young Photojournalism, Contact Photography Festival, Coalmine Gallery in Zurich, Switzerland, F3 Gallery in Berlin, Germany and Half King Gallery in New York, USA.

Anthony Cormier smokes outside a camp for migrant oil sands workers, north of Fort McMurray, April 29th, 2015. Cormier is a scaffolder and carpenter and has been working in the oil sands for over 15 years.

His widely published photographs encompass the subjects like elections and epidemics, delinquency and industrial collapse and resulting economic upheaval, migration and refugees, Greyhound Bus transport, train disasters and murder, Indigenous people and climate change disasters.. Geographically he has worked in Haiti, Honduras, Germany, France and many other countries and extensively in Canada.

Raised by a single mother Ian lived in subsidised apartment building for at-risk women. He tells us “so most of the people surrounding me while I grew up there recovering from spousal abuse or addiction on mental health issue. This was very critical part of my formation as an empathetic person. As a three-year-old I was thinking ‘why doesn’t these kids have drinking water? I was thinking about this stuff that I decided that I was going to devote my life in some capacity to having some kind of possible impact on inequality, environmental degradation that is why I became a documentary photographer. If I didn’t do documentary I probably be doing some form of activism. I fell into photography and it’s sort of became means to my end”

While talking, Ian willms’ young face reflects a positive aura of a gentle but persistent, almost ruthless crusader battling against skewed odds. His persona projects the calm compassion, a deep desire to understand and help, to do his part in the fights against inequality, against environmental degradation in the name of development detrimental to indigenous people and nature. A wisdom born out of close proximity to suffering, a passion which arose in early childhood to do something good, collaborating in documenting the mindless atrocities. His images document the devastation of pristine physical landscapes and the resulting impacts on the human emotional landscapes. The pictures show the ground level realities, human suffering from perspective of individuals going through neglect, alienation and geographical isolation.

A Syncrude tailings pond is seen on the traditional territory of the Fort McKay First Nation. At 1.5 trillion litres, the oil sands tailings ponds are the largest of their kind in the world. They house a liquid mix of toxic waste which contains dangerously high levels of mercury, arsenic, lead and benzene. Independent studies have found the the tailings ponds leak 11 million litres per day into the groundwater and Athabasca river.

Asked about his education in journalism Ian says,

“About Loyalist College, I can tell you with a certain degree of confidence that I have never drunk so much beer in my life.” He further reminisces, “Loyalist College was a lot of fun. Their curriculum could be behind the curve sometimes but I loved the people there. Time I spent there was incredibly motivating for me as a young photographer. As loyalist college is not in Toronto it is in a fairly small city of population of 50,000 people. You are kind of couple of hours from Toronto and if you are a student you may not be able to afford a car you are kind of stuck in a place and between 50 and 100 photographers who are stuck there with you. In addition to drinking a lot of beer you also spent a lot of time doing photography, a lot of time together talking about photography and when a new project comes for a photographer or world press shows their work you talk about that with your peers. This community element is sort of almost like a symposium. There was constant exchange of ideas with many people and that was really most important to basically and they had courses like International photojournalism. the work that was taught by people who honesty hadn’t really done very much of that work it was like there were showing us stuff but mostly We were learning from old Masters so they were introducing us to people like Eugene Smith, Mary Ellen mark, Eon Arbus, Gordon parks. All of these very influential classic photography Masters”

Travis Whitehead says goodbye to his mother Dorothy at her home in Fort Chipewyan AB. After years of working in the oil sands industry, Dorothy has been impacted by a mysterious, degenerative neurological condition which has limited her mobility and motor skills. Healthcare professionals working in Indigenous communities close to oil sands developments have noticed unusually high rates of Lupus. ALS, cancer and other ailments.

I inquired about his mentors

“At Loyalist, Patti Gower and Frank O’Connor were definitely a really essential influence. When I was younger I used to get a lot of guidance from Donald Weber. He teachers now. Lots of my mentors where photographers who were dead. W Eugene Smith, Mary Ellen mark is a big one like one photographer has most preferred influence about how I conduct myself as a person. Today you can contact the photographer you thought pretty amazing. Try to meet with them.”

The Syncrude oil sands upgrader plant on the traditional territory of the Fort McKay First Nation. The oil sands industry releases over 70 megatons of greenhouse gas emissions every year.

Tell us about Boreal collective & NAMARA represents

“it was very important part of my photography career. We started Boreal collective in 2010 and the idea was to challenge this kind of conservative Canadian idea of photojournalism and our country we wanted to do to long form documentary photography. We wanted to do it in a style more emotional and conceptual and there is no appetite for this type of work in Canada. So we started boreal collective to Foster and grow this kind of photography presence in our Canadian photojournalism landscape. I was one of the founding members. There were six founding members. I stayed with them for 9 years. I left because I think that running a collective like that is kind of younger persons game. If done by younger people it has a younger perspective.”

“Namara represents is a commercial agency not a photography agency, it started like that when I was more involved with it.”

A temporary water intake pipe, leads from the Athabasca river to an oil sands development near Fort McKay AB. The process of separating crude from raw oil sands bitumen consumes three barrels of fresh water for every single barrel of oil produced.

Asked about the role played by the documentation and photojournalism, and other activist in mitigation of this industrial rampage he says,

“Role of photography, visual documentation in ecological disaster is important. But in a story like this it is also needed to work in consort with scientists to explain full scope. ”

He continues, “These are not economic centres, not heavily populated; have to face indigenous peoples racial bias. They feel that if we were white people living in Toronto suburbs, we would get top priority for government. Logistics for journalists, stay, groceries, are expensive. Difficult to do journalism there due to economic factor.”

Geraldine McManus and hereditary Chief of Sagkeeng, Alma Kakikepinace light a sacred fire and celebrate one year of resistance at The Spirit of the Buffalo camp, on the Canada/US border in southern Manitoba. The camp was set up on top the Enbridge oil and gas pipelines, which connect the oil sands near Fort McMurray to Aamjiwnaang First Nation. The pipeline network has had numerous spills and other incidents, prompting strong public opposition.

He narrates his approach to a project very succinctly, “I look at it like in this case the centre point is oil sands, indigenous sovereignty & from that centre point all these branches different locations, different ideas, different moods, feelings all kind of grow. It’s like a mind map. A list of things to talk about with others. There are certain photographs that are obvious, others less obvious driven by emotional landscape so like there is physical landscape. When I was not physically there of thinking about it researching it writing about it, & organising the pictures & showing them to the people there & getting their opinion this collaboration is very imp.”

Cutlines in the Boreal Forest on land that is leased to a Suncor Oil Sands development, near Fort McKay AB. The oil industry uses cut lines to search for underground oil deposits and build infrastructure for future development.

About his advice to budding Social photojournalists he explains,

“That’s a tough one you have to kind of listen to your heart & listen to your instinct. What is calling you, motivating you, where the fire is coming from & pursue that with almost recklessness. Because you know you can never have a whole plan like how it will go. You want it intensely & for a no. of years that was what this work was; it was something I absolutely have to
do. And you know in last few years it has garnered some success & that’s great but even if it never garnered that success I would still follow through with it. Having your own emotional vulnerability in your work is great way to prove that you have concerns questions, not being afraid to show your emotions. A lot of photos I take have the projection of my own feeling. There is emotional honesty there.”

Kanahus Manuel brings her niece Wasayka, 2, to the banks of the South Thompson River, in Shuswap BC. For years, many the Secwepemc First Nations people have been rallying to protect their water and prevent a new oil sands pipeline from being built through their territory. In 2016, the pipeline was formally approved by the Canadian government and construction began in 2017. The project remains in legal limbo due to ongoing opposition from local Indigenous activists and environmental NGOs.

I wondered, “How to empathise with the related communities, population, individuals?”

“I try to have very sincere connection with people I photograph, it is very important to me to be welcomed in a place like this, very important that there is certain enthusiastic concern with people I photograph especially because I am white & I am photographing indigenous community. I have to be more respectful, that closeness. It is natural product of that approach because we all are in agreement & communicating, we may be friends or friendly with each other.”

A herd of elk feed a couple hundred metres from the route of the Trans Mountain oil sands pipeline, which runs through Jasper National Park, a UNESCO World Heritage Site in Alberta. The Canadian government and Kinder Morgan built twinned the Trans Mountain pipeline through the park in 2008, more than doubling its capacity for heavy crude.

When questioned, “Do you manage a neutral perspective?”

He told me, “I don’t believe it is possible to have totally neutral perspective. We all have opinions & they are shaped by our experience. I think what is more important is that we are aware of those biases & very aware of origins when we talk to somebody. We give an appropriate amount of weight & attention & credence to their experience & their perspective & not just hear what they say & see what they do from our perspective. I won’t call it a neutral perspective just perspective that tries to be fair, understanding.”

Joey Fraser hunts for ducks at the Métis territory of Big Point, near Fort Chipewyan AB. Traditional food sources are becoming more scarce and more polluted as time goes on. Local hunters and elders blame the vast impacts of Oil Sands developments. Studies have shown that moose meat in the area has been found to contain hundreds of times the acceptable limits of arsenic.

When I inquired about mitigation, he replied, “Big part of what I am trying to do is to create a human document of the place. It is important to show that human beings are interacting; individual lives are being impacted on, at very intimate level. Like I photographed this gentleman Warren John Simpson as he died of cancer in home. This is the kind of story that gets to people. And create outrage in public. It makes a project like that very politically dangerous for the leaders who advocate for it. This is a kind of tactics to try to curb this destruction is to show this disasters.”

Nadia Bouchier and her son Dylan share an embrace at home in Fort McKay AB, on a Saturday afternoon, just after a funeral for a fellow community member. The Fort McKay First Nation’s reserve is surrounded by oil sands developments.

About the changes over the years, he is sanguine, “It is changing. Canada is in an era of history right now when indigenous peoples are having their voices heard but it is changing in 10 years I have been doing this project. I have noticed the change, getting more recognition having more victories, government is responding in different ways, than before, more attention is paid Discussion is changing in Canada & the way Canada perceives economic future, in regard to how they must approach indigenous leadership & how they will develop resources like this in future with that in mind is changing.”

“I hope that the work I am doing today is part of that shift in this country. Everybody works together, every journalist, academician, scientist has something to say about the project like this contributes to the public understanding & shifting of opinion.”

A cut line through the Boreal Forest leads to an industrial glow on the horizon, near a Shell oil sands development, near Fort McKay AB. Canada’s Oil Sands are the largest and most environmentally destructive oil development on the planet. The industry is consuming vast swaths of Boreal forest, impacting a total land area that is roughly the size of England.


Aniruddha Cheoolkar

AFIP

Aniruddha Cheoolkar is doing photography, some commercial but mostly pictorial for last five decades. His special interest in photomicrography, taking photos through the microscope, has helped many post graduate and doctoral students in thefield of biology. Working at an environmental research laboratory he found time to teach photography, to write about his tours and experiences. He loves to read. He expresses himself fondly in poetry. His book titled “30@30” showcasing the interviews of 30 photographers was published by Jagdish Agarwal, founder of DPL.